Round 1

“The Polar Express” vs. “Home Alone”

“National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation” vs. “Elf”

“The Grinch” vs. “Rudolph”

 “A Christmas Story” vs. “It’s A Wonderful Life”

Once the votes came in, I have to admit that they took me a bit by surprise. “Home Alone”, “Elf”, “The Grinch”, and “A Christmas Story” all won their round by strides, leaving the other movies to be eliminated.